Thank you for posting these!
12 Apr 2023, 16:05
Hier könnt Ihr ein Support-Ticket erstellen.
Another Unusable Road (in Siam)
Here's one: The road between the provinces of Sukhothai and Kiang Mai is unusable; if I want to move the armoured car there, I have to go through Moulmein.
“A battle fought without determination is a battle lost.” - Josip Broz Tito
Post a Reply
Please log in to post a reply.
15 Replies
12 Apr 2023, 16:34
Try going to the border first.
You have to click right on the border, where the provinces meet.
From there, you can add to your route to keep going North.
This usually works.
Why does it work?
These roads are usually passable, but the routing algorithm is faulty.
It's not considering certain paths.
Going part way simplifies the problem.
Even the simplest algorithm can find a way from the border to the province center.
12 Apr 2023, 16:37
Thank you. I will try that now.z00mz00m wrote:
Try going to the border first.You have to click right on the border, where the provinces meet.
From there, you can add to your route to keep going North.
This usually works.
Why does it work?
These roads are usually passable, but the routing algorithm is faulty.
It's not considering certain paths.
Going part way simplifies the problem.
Even the simplest algorithm can find a way from the border to the province center.
“A battle fought without determination is a battle lost.” - Josip Broz Tito
12 Apr 2023, 16:38
It works. Thanks!
“A battle fought without determination is a battle lost.” - Josip Broz Tito
12 Apr 2023, 17:32
it considers paths that take less time to travelz00mz00m wrote:
It's not considering certain paths.
“ To command is to serve, nothing more and nothing less.”
For support ticket click here
forum rank list(the better one)
join my discord server>discord.gg/nbydn7sEaS
For support ticket click here
forum rank list(the better one)
join my discord server>discord.gg/nbydn7sEaS
12 Apr 2023, 17:50 (edited)
I'm not sure what you mean. Right mouse click doesn't do anything. Do you just mean march to the border then add a path over the border?z00mz00m wrote:
You have to click right on the border, where the provinces meet.
12 Apr 2023, 19:19
add target feature
The President
12 Apr 2023, 19:40
Yes. Most routing issues can be fixed with manual routing. You can control the route one segment at a time.
From the province center to the border. From the border to the next center. Repeat.
12 Apr 2023, 19:48 (edited)
I guess they (player) want that line, huge one.
The President
12 Apr 2023, 20:12
Claudio NVKP wrote:
I guess they want that line, huge one.
Who wants what line?
It's a hard problem, considering how often route computations happen for all the units on all the CoW maps that are running at the same time.
12 Apr 2023, 20:20
not that line, that long line that runs in the middle of something in the map. By wamt, i mean mean. By they, i mean the people who made this thread.z00mz00m wrote:
Who wants what line?Claudio NVKP wrote:
I guess they (player) want that line, huge one.It's a hard problem, considering how often route computations happen for all the units on all the CoW maps that are running at the same time.
The President
12 Apr 2023, 20:49
First, routes are calculated client side so that's no load for the server.z00mz00m wrote:
Who wants what line?Claudio NVKP wrote:
I guess they want that line, huge one.It's a hard problem, considering how often route computations happen for all the units on all the CoW maps that are running at the same time.
Second, the TSP is quite different in that it is supposed to visit ALL places, and not just find the shortest route between two places. For simple fastest-routing problems, the solutions are magnitudes of easier than the TSP.
13 Apr 2023, 18:33
Good points.
If routing is done on the client, and battles are done on the server (as they would have to be, to prevent hacking) then I can see how we might get bugs like units moving into range, firing, but not really being in range, etc.
13 Apr 2023, 18:36
Fixed. Thanks for the help guys.
“A battle fought without determination is a battle lost.” - Josip Broz Tito
13 Apr 2023, 20:40
Actually it must be programmed pretty well, or there would be MUCH more discrepancies between those.z00mz00m wrote:
Good points.If routing is done on the client, and battles are done on the server (as they would have to be, to prevent hacking) then I can see how we might get bugs like units moving into range, firing, but not really being in range, etc.
Post a Reply
Please log in to post a reply.
