Ridiculous Anti-air

You might have missed some combat earlier. Check the kills on the heavy tank.

Also, there is a bit of luck involved in combat, but not that much.

It is not OP you are just being outnumbered.

kkeeii18 wrote:

It is not OP you are just being outnumbered.

1. This indicates that previously you could have been attacked

2. SPAA performs better than reg AA.

4. SPAA is light armor and takes less damage when attacked by infantry

In 1.5 they made the anti air effective against tanks, especially heavy armor. Its basically a cheap anti tank gun. Its stats can compare with the anti tank gun.

Especially if you are using an AXIS doctrine country. Which historically makes sense, AA from German 88 guns were used against tanks with high effectiveness.

Tribunate wrote:

Especially if you are using an AXIS doctrine country. Which historically makes sense, AA from German 88 guns were used against tanks with high effectiveness.

Ggoddkkiller wrote:

Anti-air units are so ridiculously powerful this must be a bug or something, for example here is 1 heavy tank + 1 anti air vs 1 SP anti air and SP anti air is attacking side: (Every unit had full HP)

This is the damage heavy tank group took:

https://hizliresim.com/xKjU9g

While this is the damage SP anti air took:

https://hizliresim.com/JHEjHE

While in reality SP anti air is both extremely cheap and easy to produce unit compared to heavy tanks and a heavy tank should easily destory them especially while defending but they are performing better than heavy tanks?? Seriously what is this??? No wonder this guy is producing only anti air and SP anti air...

Your screenshot shows that there are more units involved. All units deal out their damage in an area of 5, and receive returning damage from all units in that area of 5 as well. Meaning in the combat above all units nearby are involved, not just the 1 SP Anti air.

A single SP Anti Air of course wouldnt defeat you and isnt particularly strong. Everything works as intended here.

freezy wrote:

Ggoddkkiller wrote:

Anti-air units are so ridiculously powerful this must be a bug or something, for example here is 1 heavy tank + 1 anti air vs 1 SP anti air and SP anti air is attacking side: (Every unit had full HP)

This is the damage heavy tank group took:

https://hizliresim.com/xKjU9g

While this is the damage SP anti air took:

https://hizliresim.com/JHEjHE

While in reality SP anti air is both extremely cheap and easy to produce unit compared to heavy tanks and a heavy tank should easily destory them especially while defending but they are performing better than heavy tanks?? Seriously what is this??? No wonder this guy is producing only anti air and SP anti air...

The SP Anti Air shown in the screenshot is on elite level, while your troops are not.Your screenshot shows that there are more units involved. All units deal out their damage in an area of 5, and receive returning damage from all units in that area of 5 as well. Meaning in the combat above al units nearby are involved, not just the 1 SP Anti air.

A single SP Anti Air of course wouldnt defeat you and isnt particularly strong. Everything works as intended here.

By the way im not ranting at all as i defeated him easily by quickly capturing his core territories but it doesn't mean SPAA has any reasonable stats as they are far cheaper and easy to produce than heavy tanks then anybody could explain please why should we produce heavy tanks instead of spamming SPAA if they have such high anti-armor damage even while attacking???

Because Heavy tanks still easily beat SPAA if you compare them 1on1 or in terms of invested resources. Just compare the stats: On maximum level the SPAA does 10.6 defense damage and 5.3 attack damage against heavy armor and has 80 HP, while the heavy tank on max level does 25 defending damage and 25 attack damage against light armor and has 155 HP.

The SPAA in your example likely didnt take too much damage in one hit because the damage was split among all nearby units and it happened that the other units nearby therefore soaked up parts of the damage.

Nobody noticed that stats was from CoW 1.0?

Pretty sure they're from 1.5

A level 3 heavy tank and a level 5 AA with only 55 HP, an elite SPAA with 10 HP. I'm not sure if this is 1.5?