X factor Nonsense

Is it possible you are fighting a ghost? Or looking at the HP of a ghost?

nope they are there. and it is happening in more than 1 battle. I watched the timer click down over and over and saw the result. 0 damage to enemy. MY units took damage, tho. doesnt happen every battle every time, but its happening more than it should. I saw a level 1 infantry with 1 hit point get hit with 3 of my arty 3 times and take no damage. thats besides the infantry that was attacking it hand to hand, with NO damage for 3 turns to the enemy

The variance does sometimes result in zero damage, more or less, depending on the strength of your units, but this sounds like it might be something other than the normal variance.

yeah it does happen i just never saw it do it over and over. usually i see it when you first attack.it seems that first attack never does that well.

I haven't gotten the impression that the first attack is weaker, but maybe you pay attention to that one more often. But multiple no hits obviously can happen. It's possible to flip heads 10 times in a row, but it's pretty unlikely.

still happening. lvl2 arty bombards a lvl 1 armored car, which is sitting in urban btw, and no damage done to armored car.

ok scenario continues. lvl 1 tacbomber attacks same ac, no damage done to ac. shortly after, i sent a single lvl2 ac and attacked the enemy ac. no damage done to enemy, mine lost half its hit points. absolutely ridiculous. something is wrong

Hi, can you please give all the details how to reproduce this?

- which map

- units attacked + condition

- attacking units + condition

- which province

- attack happening from which side (from where)

- results from each tick

Is it happening all the time with these conditions or just sometimes?

This may be unrelated, but, at least when using artillery, I've seen the HP of the target not change until after I reloaded the game, even with the target was not a ghost.