Philosophical Chatter in Global Chat

"ERWIN_ROMMEL997: this is more educational than what my teachers teach me"

So I thought I'd post it here.

Here it Starts:

user12819045: Do you think wars are pointless?

Hornetkeeper: They're probably a inevitable consequence of transformations in society

user12819045: Yes I guess

Hornetkeeper: Like, the dreadful ideologies could've spread a lot more if ww2 didn't point at their danger

Balkan_God: spidermans last movie was like (????)??(???)??(????)

user12819045: Or else we would be living in stone age

Hornetkeeper: and we'd have a dystopia from Orwell's 1984 here

Hornetkeeper: Naturally, when civilization evolves, its structures need to change

Hornetkeeper: Which means there's often a mismatch between structures that were previously in harmony

Hornetkeeper: And I think the real virtue is evolving without losing harmony, not staying intact to preserve harmony

user12819045: And I guess human lives need to be sacrificed to end a war

user12819045: And start a war

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: War is a way to solve human disagreement

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: Also at times, war is needed which is unfortunate.

Hornetkeeper: Generally, youu need to undergo a degradation to replace the current structure with a more adaptive one

Hornetkeeper: you have to let go of certain things, which might interfere with the stability, but in the long run, the structure you establish afterwards will be better

Hornetkeeper: some people don't understand that, so they ie build an interpretive structure based on a claim (their opinion usually) and then protect it at all costs

Hornetkeeper: they don't want to lose their interpretive structure, so when you argue against them they just get extremely angry to wreak havoc and get away from the og issue

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: if the world was one without nations and divergence I don't think wars would've existed, but it's likely for the world to be to divided once it becomes united.

Hornetkeeper: If you Let go of your opinions, you might lose sth you used to take as granted knowledge, and sth that actually worked, but in the long run you'll gain sth that actually works now

Hornetkeeper: if you do this in response to your opinion being wrong that is

Hornetkeeper: A world without divergence would be too chaotic

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: opposite

Hornetkeeper: You need some exactly defined structures and some inequality to organize

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: by divergence I mean nations and borders.

Hornetkeeper: if you just give everyone equal status, no one organizes anything

Hornetkeeper: Oh, yeah. That could be good, but it would probably be too utopian

Hornetkeeper: And when you put people into utopian conditions, they cause trouble just so they don't get bored, that's what Dostoyevsky claimed

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: interesting

Hornetkeeper: we're used to some degree of chaos and uncertainty, because you need to confront Chaos to learn new things and adapt yourself

Marshal Chukov: Sending More Troops From Finland To Norway. PRAISE THE FATHERLAND OF FINLSND! HEIL MARSHALL CHULOV VII

Ahmad_Thakur: ?

Hornetkeeper: so we have a natural instinct to seek some degree of chaos and disorder, it changes the conditions so it teaches you new things

Marshal Chukov: Say Marshal If You Want To Join My Alliance.

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: in simple terms

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: mistakes are needed for progress

Hornetkeeper: ^

Marshal Chukov: Erwin

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: hello

someone1939: hmm

Ahmad_Thakur: hermann goriing was obese to me

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: also if the world had no borders then wars wouldn't exist but police would be there for crimes and stuff

Marshal Chukov: Will you in the Finnish court join me in a alliance.

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: the reason why the US is economically and militarily successful is because of unity, there's barley any divergence in the states.

Hornetkeeper: depends Rommel, to what degree the politics within the former countries would be as harmonic as the inter-(formerly) national affairs

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: Texas alone has a higher gpd than Russia

Hornetkeeper: gdp?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: but that's because of other factors as well

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: my mistaek

Marshal Chukov: The policy of theirs is national. That's why.

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: mistake

Ahmad_Thakur: mistake?

Hornetkeeper: But Russia has coal, oil, iron and uranium, that's more important...

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: mistake*

Hornetkeeper: gas as well

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: in terms of resources you're right

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: probably has one of the most

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: I think China does

Hornetkeeper: Russia is an example of excess totalitarian order

Hornetkeeper: the agenda is so strictly defined that you can't adjust it, though you can act against the agenda

Ahmad_Thakur: totalitarian?

Marshal Chukov: Hornet Russia Has Plutonium And Power Plants They are

Making The World More Polluted With The Fuels.

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: totalitarian order is good as long as the leader knows what he's doing

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: he lol

Hornetkeeper: they certainly do, but that causes a lot of distrust and incapability of true cooperation

Hornetkeeper: they also don't have the capitalist free market to select the most competent people to run the economy

Hornetkeeper: which China does have partly, they call it socialist free market

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: Combination of Socialism and Capitalism would be good

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: rip

Hornetkeeper: but the leader can't know what he's doing unless the whole system is well designed to be open to change

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: true

Balkan_God: sup outkast

Ahmad_Thakur: how long does a europe road to war game usually lasts?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: totalitarianism is against that

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: there's ups and downs to everything

user14440925: Yeah

Hornetkeeper: the ideologies are just a small part of the truth deceitfully applied to everything

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: what's the truth anyways?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: there's so many definitions of it

Hornetkeeper: The truth is complexity, we don't really have a 100% truth

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: and the truth is that there is only on truth

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: one*

Ahmad_Thakur: may i suggest?

Hornetkeeper: But a truthful path in life is adjusting and letting go of things youu know are functionally wrong

GENERALQUARTERS: what is the definitiion of is?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: that's one definition out of plenty

Ahmad_Thakur: we have 100% truth if one can understand it

user14440925: Why is this happening in a map game

Hornetkeeper: If you use a claim to predict an outcome of a situation, and youu predict it well, that's a functional truth

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: and there is only one truth, which means that the possibilities of you knowing the truth is low.

Hornetkeeper: and functional truths change when you change environment

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: that's one form of truth yes

Hms Bismarck: I have a urge to swear this player who is already taking cities from my enemies

Hms Bismarck: I warned him about taking land I fought for but he thus his British so he can boss me around

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: but facts however

Hornetkeeper: think about it like that: the ultimate chaos is the truth. Your work is to simplify it so that you even have the capacity to conceptualize it, but not oversimplify it and create a strictly defined "truth", then it turns into ultimate deception

Ahmad_Thakur: but what if the truth doesnt change witht the change in environment?

Marshal Chukov: HMS Bismarck It's KMS Bismarck

Hornetkeeper: The virtue is to simplify the truth as well as you can while creating as little deception as possible

Hornetkeeper: take what you're taught in school, the claims change over time

Ahmad_Thakur: theres no deception in truth

Hornetkeeper: you can call all things particles or objects at some point, then you learn about particles in superpositions and learn that objects are just a fictional simplification of the infinitely complex universe

Ahmad_Thakur: thats why truth is one

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: "the truth hurts"

Hornetkeeper: tell me a banal thing that's surely true Ahmad

Ahmad_Thakur: banal?

Hornetkeeper: yup, it's the healthy form of pain mostly

Hornetkeeper: yes

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: but what if the truth is that there is no truth

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: but facts

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: wait no

Hms Bismarck: It’s Hms bismarck

Ahmad_Thakur: i dont want to get to religion but you can guess it what i mean

KrAzYKiLLeRII: Sup guys

KrAzYKiLLeRII: How’s everyone today

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: decent

Hornetkeeper: There's no truth but facts? Then, why do we like stories so much?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: stories relate to facts

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: there is no one truth

Ahmad_Thakur: i dont like stories

Hornetkeeper: because they're an abstraction of a principle from a ton of situations, like, you take 100 evil people, abstract their behaviour and create the "uultimate evil" archetype

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: wait the one truth is a fact

Hornetkeeper: but that's not a truth, just a fiction

Hornetkeeper: that's more functional than a truth...

Ahmad_Thakur: listen

Marshal Chukov: Huh..

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: Science is the truth?

Hornetkeeper: when you watch a cartoon movie, what you're seeing is certainly not facts... violet cows

Ahmad_Thakur: science is deception likehornet said

Marshal Chukov: Oh

Ahmad_Thakur: changing witht the environment

Marshal Chukov: Which could mean more uranium?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: deceived by who?

Hornetkeeper: let's put it like that: truth doesn't change with the environment. However, the environment is infinitely complex. And the part we're inhabiting constantly changes

Ahmad_Thakur: your ultimate evil out of 100 doesnt define ultimate evil cuz there will be someone more evil than him

Edit: I didn't see that one, but: making a picture of the most evil thing imaginable is literally the point of an archetype

If you have above 10k manpower, you're not investing properly. A good player never has many resources.
Larger armies destroy enemies faster without taking damage from them.
Build only: 1 military building in each city, airstrips, and recruiting stations to boost manpower.
Minimize research, 2 unit types early, 6 types in late game. Upgrade old units, but: artillery lv1 to lv2 is a waste, only lv1 to lv4 is worth it.
Enjoy
Hornetkeeper

8 Replies

Marshal Chukov: Cuz my country is busy making a atomic power station.

Hornetkeeper: So, we have to forget certain truths and adopt new ones to survive, we can't know all the truth, just the part of it that's currently relevant

Ahmad_Thakur: we never found the truth really

Hornetkeeper: and, the truth is just something our consciousness thinks up

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: we never will?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: programmed

Ahmad_Thakur: i dont think so

Hornetkeeper: You can't even say what a cup is truthfully, it's a complex thing, tons of atoms and even smaller particles

Ahmad_Thakur: theres someone knowing all the truth and limiting our capacity to know the truth

Hornetkeeper: However, you know how to use a cup, and that's the functional truth - like a simplification - which actually navigates you through the world

Hornetkeeper: you cathegorize the complex world into things, according to its relation to you. If sth is useful, youu define it as a thing and stop bothering about the details

Ahmad_Thakur: hornet functional truth is something we have been taught

Hornetkeeper: Even the taxonomy is a lie, there's no such thing as a species

Hornetkeeper: But there's groups of objects we thought up that are called animals, and we group them into Kingdom Animalia because they happen to share certain features

Hornetkeeper: So it's easier to understand for us when they're divided taxonomically like that

Ahmad_Thakur: well they are categorized arent they?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: what's the best way to gain knowledge?

Hornetkeeper: exactly, and cathegorizations are simpler than the truth

Hornetkeeper: so they mostly work, but not always

Ahmad_Thakur: they are categorized in nature

Hornetkeeper: and the ultimate truth is just too complex, so we simplify it and abstract the parts of it that we need

Ahmad_Thakur: who made them...categorized them

Hornetkeeper: thats my point

Ahmad_Thakur: exactly exactly

Hornetkeeper: People cathegorized them, because if they didn't, the things around them would be so complex they couldn't even get up from bed

Ahmad_Thakur: the truth is beyond human reach

user13872600: No

choppa XIV: hi

Hornetkeeper: You don't get up from bed by ordering each of your 30 trillion cells to move

Alphonse de Solis: bruh lmao my enemy has been sieging my city for more than 5 hours already

Hornetkeeper: You simplify it into a function, which automatically does it for you every time

user13872600: Then why don't you destroy his siege

Ahmad_Thakur: you mean people simplified it??

Hornetkeeper: just like you simplify all the atoms outside into objects that are used for the same thing each time

Hornetkeeper: yeah, if people didn't realize that specks of dust weren't dangerous, they'd never achieve anything

Hornetkeeper: Only when they realized that and started ignoring specks of dust, it worked

user13872600: ?

Hornetkeeper: and ignoring specks of dust = ignoring a certain part of the truth because it's not valuable atm

user13872600: Whats your point

Ahmad_Thakur: another example plz

Marshal Chukov: Ahead wats ur country.

Hornetkeeper: oh yeah. Why do you think your eyes concentrate on one place?

Ahmad_Thakur: they are made this way

Ahmad_Thakur: we dont know why

Hornetkeeper: haha, you can answer that from many perspectives, layers of analysis

Ahmad_Thakur: ok but

Hornetkeeper: But here's a reasonable claim: You need to concentrate on important things to be able to process them

Marshal Chukov: Why are you ignoring me

Hornetkeeper: If you focused on everything at once you'd overheat, so you focus on one thing

Ahmad_Thakur: can anybody answer why you cant focus on right while looking to the left?

Hornetkeeper: That means you simplify the truth, you only pay attention to what's relevant

shinyoochan: what does technician grade mean?

Alphonse de Solis: I'm defending that's why, attacking is not a good idea. I deal more damage when defending

Hornetkeeper: those are ranks, you gain them as you kill active players' units and build buildings

Alphonse de Solis: My enemy kept sending more to their infantry to their deaths

Ahmad_Thakur: why we overheat?why cant we just process more?

Alphonse de Solis: More of*

Ahmad_Thakur: cuz we are made this way and limited

Hornetkeeper: Ahmad, because we couldn't evolve into more sophisticated creatures in such a short time

Alphonse de Solis: Why are you answering yourself?

Hornetkeeper: We have fractal genes for example, which say sth like: the ratio length to width of a tracheis segment is always 5:1 regardless of scale

Hornetkeeper: But, the ideal ratio is a bit different for each scale

Ahmad_Thakur: but we evolved into this from a prokaryote in just 4 billion years?

Ahmad_Thakur: impossible

Hornetkeeper: lol tracheids are for plants, how did I confuse that

Hide_Your_Capital: Return to Monke

Hornetkeeper: yes Ahmad, because the world is analogical, there's a lot of principles that apply to different things

Ahmad_Thakur: ok ok listen bud i have a question then

Hornetkeeper: for example, the Investment Continuity principle: if you put effort into something, get to a resultt, it's better for you to exploit the result in your future activities and expand it than start doing sth else

Ahmad_Thakur: why do prokaryotes still exist in the same environment and same conditions?

Hornetkeeper: you follow an effort with a result by making another effort that makes use of the result

Hornetkeeper: that's an Analogical Principle that applies to very many things

Hornetkeeper: Prokaryotes are simple, so they don't create enough complexity for themselves

Hornetkeeper: we're advanced, so we need to do a lot of extra things to survive

Hide_Your_Capital: Well Ahmed did you know that flowering plants started existing only after the dinosaurs died

Hornetkeeper: That means our relation with the environment is way more complex than that of prokaryotes

Ahmad_Thakur: lol what cap

Hornetkeeper: Prokaryotes can survive so many things because their simple body has so few needs and hence can adapt to almost impossible conditions

If you have above 10k manpower, you're not investing properly. A good player never has many resources.
Larger armies destroy enemies faster without taking damage from them.
Build only: 1 military building in each city, airstrips, and recruiting stations to boost manpower.
Minimize research, 2 unit types early, 6 types in late game. Upgrade old units, but: artillery lv1 to lv2 is a waste, only lv1 to lv4 is worth it.
Enjoy
Hornetkeeper

Ahmad_Thakur: herbivores only ate leaves back then?

Hide_Your_Capital: Yes

Ahmad_Thakur: then why did it evolve?

Hide_Your_Capital: Bro herbivores always ate plants, wth

Ahmad_Thakur: herbivores eat fruits too

Hornetkeeper: wdym Ahmad?

Hornetkeeper: why did what evolve?

snomaker98: good morning everyone looks like a very deap topic this morning

Hide_Your_Capital: Different climeatic conditions differed

Ahmad_Thakur: like you mean it can survive cuz it isnt that complex

Ahmad_Thakur: prokaryote

Ahmad_Thakur: then why did it evolve into us or anything when it didnt needed

Hide_Your_Capital: There have been 4 groups of plants that have existed on earth

HAMAD77HD7: How to make my own world

Hornetkeeper: Because the more complex organisms are more advanced, so they can make new use of the environment

Ahmad_Thakur: am literally 2 on 1 rn lol

Hide_Your_Capital: I only read about angiosperm, the flowering plants

Hornetkeeper: And expand out, while prokaryotes survive in their extreme conditions, which the complex life cannot inhabit at some point

Ahmad_Thakur: hold on

HAMAD77HD7: Is there a way for me to make a world?

Ahmad_Thakur: which came first?

Hornetkeeper: But, when the complex life exploits more of the world, it's also dependant more on the world

Ahmad_Thakur: human or prokaryote

Hide_Your_Capital: Hammand yes, but you need high command I think

Hornetkeeper: which means it can advance a lot more but is also way more likely to get eradicated by environmental changes

Hide_Your_Capital: Bro prokaryote

Hornetkeeper: complex life = human

Ahmad_Thakur: so you evolve from simple to complex?

Ahmad_Thakur: its the opposite of universal truth

Hide_Your_Capital: Yes

user14414952: Hi

Hornetkeeper: yes, and complex gets eradicated every time it evolves into the wrong kind of complex

Ahmad_Thakur: everything tends to simplify

HAMAD77HD7: So how do I make a world?

Hornetkeeper: No, you evolve from simple to complex, and you evolve to be better at simplifying so you can deal with the fact you're complex

Hornetkeeper: Hamad, you need high command for that

Ahmad_Thakur: that doesnt make sense

TheCaptainBlood: I answered him in help chat

Hornetkeeper: if you evolve from complex to simple, why did humans evolve?

Ahmad_Thakur: thats the point

Ahmad_Thakur: humans didnt evolve

Hide_Your_Capital: Wth

Ahmad_Thakur: they are made in a limited capacity of thiking and knowing the truth

Balkan_God: hey cap

Ahmad_Thakur: have you ever made a simple thing more complex for youself? never

Hide_Your_Capital: Bro i am contemplating my life choices right now after seeing char

Hornetkeeper: no Ahmad, because you tend to simplify things because there's too much complexity

Ahmad_Thakur: see

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: but you can make complex things simplistic

Hornetkeeper: That's natural, you evolve to be more complex, so you have to adopt sth that simplifies this complexity enough for youu, so you understand it

Hornetkeeper: don't youu see the point?

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: this is more educational than what my teachers teach me

Hide_Your_Capital: Same

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: it's because school relies in inauthentic learning

Ahmad_Thakur: do you believe we are going to evolve?

Hide_Your_Capital: I am in between online school right now

Ahmad_Thakur: or just adapt to the environment changes?

Ahmad_Thakur: artificially

Hornetkeeper: depends. We might be the wrong kind of complexity

ShinTheGreat: Hi

Hide_Your_Capital: Teaching pressure, weight and molecules of gad at NTP

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: Psychologist Herman says that 95% of the things that you memorise in school will be forgotten once you finished with your exams

Hide_Your_Capital: Gas*

Hornetkeeper: See it like that: most of the time we evolved to exploit everything as best as we could. That's what made species dominate right?

Ahmad_Thakur: nothing evolved into wrong kind of complexity really

Ahmad_Thakur: the environment just changed afterwards

Hornetkeeper: So we're a species that's used to exploiting, being in a situation where we must not exploit

Hornetkeeper: this might be an universal killer that got rid of all civilization s of the universe

Hornetkeeper: possible reason why we haven't found any yet

Ahmad_Thakur: i understand you now

Ahmad_Thakur: but

Ahmad_Thakur: answer this

Hide_Your_Capital: You ever head about the Fermi paradox?

Hornetkeeper: heard that somewhere, but no idea what it is

Ahmad_Thakur: dinosaurs were more dangerous than us...but they got extinct cuz they were complex enough?

Hide_Your_Capital: Why we haven't foundan extrastesstrial life form?

Art_Of_War 1944: Hallo

Hide_Your_Capital: Ahmad simple words, asteroid strike

Hornetkeeper: Dinosaurs got extinct because there was a sudden environmental change, the meteorite and other things as well

Ahmad_Thakur: there isnt any OR we are not supposed to

Hornetkeeper: Which meant, the things the dinosaurs exploited, that allowed them to live, suddenly became unavailable

Ahmad_Thakur: so what are you talking about complexities??

Hide_Your_Capital: No, they just got unlucky, if dinosaurs survived, we wouldn't be here where we are

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: Was Adam and eve created before dinosaurs?

Ahmad_Thakur: no rommel

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: oh shoot controversial

Art_Of_War 1944: XD

Ahmad_Thakur: hide i completely agree with you

Hornetkeeper: Adam and Eve creation is an archetypal story

DEATHBOOM22: death

Hornetkeeper: It's an abstraction of some kind of principle, that's why it got told and preserved so long

ERWIN_ROMMEL997: but it's the first creation of god in this planet according to Abrahamic relgions

Ahmad_Thakur: hornet listened hide?|

Hornetkeeper: And those are abstractions of "eternal" aspects of life like order and chaos, so you can't put them within a timeframe

Hide_Your_Capital: Bro why you gotta bring religion here

If you have above 10k manpower, you're not investing properly. A good player never has many resources.
Larger armies destroy enemies faster without taking damage from them.
Build only: 1 military building in each city, airstrips, and recruiting stations to boost manpower.
Minimize research, 2 unit types early, 6 types in late game. Upgrade old units, but: artillery lv1 to lv2 is a waste, only lv1 to lv4 is worth it.
Enjoy
Hornetkeeper

Question:- user12819045: Do you think wars are pointless?

Answer:- Hide_Your_Capital: Bro why you gotta bring religion here

The President

hide yo kids, hide yo wife but most importantly, Hide_Your_Capital

damn that's a lot of text.

i have my own opinions on this, wouldve shared, but didn't as me no smart.

"In my humble opinion, on the subject matter, topic and content discussed beforehand; I would like to humbly propose, convey my idea on the subject and remark; this, with the help of the afforementioned post" - Karl von Krass
"The Golden Spire is looking for members, Anyone with good sense of game mechanics and a discord account can apply"
Secretary of Nova0213

Karl von Krass wrote:

i have my own opinions on this, wouldve shared, but didn't as me no smart.
Please make sure you're lying here, I've heard that speaking the truth is against the law :D
If you have above 10k manpower, you're not investing properly. A good player never has many resources.
Larger armies destroy enemies faster without taking damage from them.
Build only: 1 military building in each city, airstrips, and recruiting stations to boost manpower.
Minimize research, 2 unit types early, 6 types in late game. Upgrade old units, but: artillery lv1 to lv2 is a waste, only lv1 to lv4 is worth it.
Enjoy
Hornetkeeper

Hornetkeeper wrote:

Karl von Krass wrote:

i have my own opinions on this, wouldve shared, but didn't as me no smart.
Please make sure you're lying here, I've heard that speaking the truth is against the law :D
ooopps, i meant, you kindergarteners Kan't handle my 33 PHDs (11 PHDs in 3 nations) and my Certification of Karling. My view of life is wholly incomprehensible to you, Simple organisms by comparison.
"In my humble opinion, on the subject matter, topic and content discussed beforehand; I would like to humbly propose, convey my idea on the subject and remark; this, with the help of the afforementioned post" - Karl von Krass
"The Golden Spire is looking for members, Anyone with good sense of game mechanics and a discord account can apply"
Secretary of Nova0213

Post a Reply

Please log in to post a reply.

Back to Discussions
Quick Launch