Rehxor's 1949 RP - Related "Chit-Chat"

Claudio NVKP wrote:

Sophisticated forum game.

Okay, so are we still on the track to start tomorrow?

I think so.

Carking the 6th wrote:

Deb wrote:

Carking the 6th wrote:

Deb wrote:

Ratko M wrote:

Hi, what's this about a RP? Never played one in CoW before, but I would be interested in joining.

Why are you so mean?

What do you mean? He never said anything mean. Just showed interest in joining this RP.

He said "F*ck croatia" and was praising Milosevic.

Oh for the love of god we have supporters of the RS too now? What’s next? A Turkish nationalist?

Who what and why?

Carking the 6th wrote:

Who what and why?

I also don't hate the current govermenet though.

How though? Germany doesn’t need any king to respect or unite behind! I don’t see it bringing in any money like the crown lands and maybe tourism does in the UK.

And we saw what the Kaisers bloodline did to Germany…

Carking the 6th wrote:

How though? Germany doesn’t need any king to respect or unite behind! I don’t see it bringing in any money like the crown lands and maybe tourism does in the UK.

And we saw what the Kaisers bloodline did to Germany…

Then please tell me. How will it improve the country or its people’s lives?

Kaiser Wilhelm wasn't very good at well, war. However Germany was thriving in 1914(before the war). I also think that if WWI was avoided; Germany would do even better under Wilhelm's son.

Did you mean in an alternate history? I thought you meant for Germany to return to monarchy today! Even if constitutional I didn’t see what a country has to gain by propping up some king out of nowhere lol. But honestly any Germany that isn’t Nazi is better so I’d have taken that over what we got…

Carking the 6th wrote:

Then please tell me. How will it improve the country or its people’s lives?

I really don't want to argue. However, I will give you some reasons

1.) A good monarch can bring more stabilty.(In my oponion it should have limited power if it is a bad monarch)

2.) The Kaiser has brought good times to people in the past. i think it can do so agian in present day.

3.) I belive Germany should be more conservative.

Carking the 6th wrote:

Did you mean in an alternate history? I thought you meant for Germany to return to monarchy today! Even if constitutional I didn’t see what a country has to gain by propping up some king out of nowhere lol. But honestly any Germany that isn’t Nazi is better so I’d have taken that over what we got…

Oh no I was genuinely asking that question there.

Well I don’t know enough about the current state of Germany but from the outside it looks stable.. I’ll just take your word for it.

The Kaiser and conservative monarchies also caused the First World War. I mean I guess if they are just figure heads they can act like the queen in a matriarchal figure but even now the British monarchy seems on its way out. I am from a country with a monarchy and while the king is somewhat popular I mean it doesn’t really bring that much to the country that a strong arm dictator wouldn’t. Probably because we don’t have that much of national identity (like we do but we also associate with other countries) and the king is not very limited.

But here is the most important thing:COMMUNISM! You are the leader of the Danube union! You just not believe these falsifications! Now move on for the glory of communism!

Just a question... this RP starts in 1949 right? At which stage the Soviets hadn't given back Manchuria to the Chinese, the KMT was still somewhat favoured as more viable by the USSR, and the Civil War was still raging around the country. This was a fairly major part of the Cold War and impacted cross-strait relations, the Sino-Soviet Split, the three wars in Korea, Vietnam, and Malaya, &c.

So who is playing Communist China, how will the Civil War work, is there a possibility of KMT victory, et cetera?

Also, Korea. Is the ROK played as extension of Japan, DPRK by Manchukuo, or something else?

Lord Crayfish wrote:

Just a question... this RP starts in 1949 right? At which stage the Soviets hadn't given back Manchuria to the Chinese, the KMT was still somewhat favoured as more viable by the USSR, and the Civil War was still raging around the country. This was a fairly major part of the Cold War and impacted cross-strait relations, the Sino-Soviet Split, the three wars in Korea, Vietnam, and Malaya, &c.

So who is playing Communist China, how will the Civil War work, is there a possibility of KMT victory, et cetera?

Also, Korea. Is the ROK played as extension of Japan, DPRK by Manchukuo, or something else?

So, I don’t think any of this is relevant

SamPGS_17 wrote:

Lord Crayfish wrote:

Just a question... this RP starts in 1949 right? At which stage the Soviets hadn't given back Manchuria to the Chinese, the KMT was still somewhat favoured as more viable by the USSR, and the Civil War was still raging around the country. This was a fairly major part of the Cold War and impacted cross-strait relations, the Sino-Soviet Split, the three wars in Korea, Vietnam, and Malaya, &c.

So who is playing Communist China, how will the Civil War work, is there a possibility of KMT victory, et cetera?

Also, Korea. Is the ROK played as extension of Japan, DPRK by Manchukuo, or something else?

If you looked at the map, you’d see it’s the 22p map, not HWW

So, I don’t think any of this is relevant

I'd like to participate if you don't mind

Carking the 6th wrote:

Oh no I was genuinely asking that question there.

Well I don’t know enough about the current state of Germany but from the outside it looks stable.. I’ll just take your word for it.

The Kaiser and conservative monarchies also caused the First World War. I mean I guess if they are just figure heads they can act like the queen in a matriarchal figure but even now the British monarchy seems on its way out. I am from a country with a monarchy and while the king is somewhat popular I mean it doesn’t really bring that much to the country that a strong arm dictator wouldn’t. Probably because we don’t have that much of national identity (like we do but we also associate with other countries) and the king is not very limited.

But here is the most important thing:COMMUNISM! You are the leader of the Danube union! You just not believe these falsifications! Now move on for the glory of communism!

Lord Crayfish wrote:

SamPGS_17 wrote:

Lord Crayfish wrote:

Just a question... this RP starts in 1949 right? At which stage the Soviets hadn't given back Manchuria to the Chinese, the KMT was still somewhat favoured as more viable by the USSR, and the Civil War was still raging around the country. This was a fairly major part of the Cold War and impacted cross-strait relations, the Sino-Soviet Split, the three wars in Korea, Vietnam, and Malaya, &c.

So who is playing Communist China, how will the Civil War work, is there a possibility of KMT victory, et cetera?

Also, Korea. Is the ROK played as extension of Japan, DPRK by Manchukuo, or something else?

If you looked at the map, you’d see it’s the 22p map, not HWW So, I don’t think any of this is relevant

Yeah now I realised too late, not sure how to delete posts.I'd like to participate if you don't mind