Supremacy Logo

What was the most decisive battle ?

What was the most decisive battle from World War II?

There were many battles , some more important than others ,What do you think was the most important ?


"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula

Post a Reply

Please log in to post a reply.

31 Replies

17 Oct 2015, 00:58

This is tough. I'm not sure what to pick. I'll have to think about this.

Forum Gang Premier
you are a balls
17 Oct 2015, 00:59

Sir McSquiggles wrote:

Pearl Harbor! Its what got the US into the war!
It is true , in my opinion the most important battle was the Normandy landings, the Normandy landings caused the fall of Germany, the invasion marked 2 fronts for Germany.

"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:04

I vote for pearl harbor. It got the US into the war, and led to the defeat of Japan and Germany. If Normandy didn't happen, the allies would still have troops in Italy, and Germany would be fighting a war on two fronts soon enough. Normandy just sped up the process.

Forum Gang Premier
you are a balls
17 Oct 2015, 01:05

The most important battle was Normandy, the landing caused the fall of the German Army .


"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:06

GreatbigHippo wrote:

I vote for pearl harbor. It got the US into the war, and led to the defeat of Japan and Germany. If Normandy didn't happen, the allies would still have troops in Italy, and Germany would be fighting a war on two fronts soon enough. Normandy just sped up the process.
The Battle of Stalingrad was more decisive than Pearl Harbor.

"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:06

But if it weren't for pearl harbor, the battle of Normandy likely would have never happened, and if it did not in the force in which it did.

Felipe V de Borbon wrote:

The Battle of Stalingrad was more decisive than Pearl Harbor.

Forum Gang Premier
you are a balls
17 Oct 2015, 01:08

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

I vote for pearl harbor. It got the US into the war, and led to the defeat of Japan and Germany. If Normandy didn't happen, the allies would still have troops in Italy, and Germany would be fighting a war on two fronts soon enough. Normandy just sped up the process.
The Battle of Stalingrad was more decisive than Pearl Harbor.
In Europe, yes, but not in the pacific. If pearl harbor never happened, Japan would not have been defeated.
Forum Gang Premier
you are a balls
17 Oct 2015, 01:08

GreatbigHippo wrote:

But if it weren't for pearl harbor, the battle of Normandy likely would have never happened, and if it did not in the force in which it did.
True, but still, Normandy operation would have worked.

"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:09

Sir McSquiggles wrote:

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

The most important battle was Normandy, the landing caused the fall of the German Army .
Normandy wouldnt have happened if it werent for US involvement. Pearl harbor= Normandy invasion.
True..

"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:10

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

But if it weren't for pearl harbor, the battle of Normandy likely would have never happened, and if it did not in the force in which it did.
True, but still, Normandy operation would have worked.
Maybe.
Forum Gang Premier
you are a balls
17 Oct 2015, 01:11

Change my vote to Stalingrad.


"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:12

GreatbigHippo wrote:

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

But if it weren't for pearl harbor, the battle of Normandy likely would have never happened, and if it did not in the force in which it did.
True, but still, Normandy operation would have worked.
Maybe.
Churchill would fight to the end.

"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 01:13

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

But if it weren't for pearl harbor, the battle of Normandy likely would have never happened, and if it did not in the force in which it did.
True, but still, Normandy operation would have worked.
Maybe.
Churchill would fight to the end.
True, but that doesn't mean he would have won.
Forum Gang Premier
you are a balls
17 Oct 2015, 01:16

GreatbigHippo wrote:

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

Felipe V de Borbon. wrote:

GreatbigHippo wrote:

But if it weren't for pearl harbor, the battle of Normandy likely would have never happened, and if it did not in the force in which it did.
True, but still, Normandy operation would have worked.
Maybe.
Churchill would fight to the end.
True, but that doesn't mean he would have won.
It is possible, although Churchill have good strategy

"Los cobardes agonizan muchas veces antes de morir...los valientes no se dan ni cuenta de su muerte" Julio César.
"En la guerra los acontecimientos importantes son el resultado de causas triviales" Julio César.
"Que me odien con tal de que me teman" Calígula
17 Oct 2015, 04:33

In summer 1941, the Germans could have made a decisive advance on Moscow. The defenders were so ill-equipped after 3 weeks of war, some of them went into battle with no weapons. Russia already had contigency plans to continue the war from Siberia. If Moscow would have fallen in 1941, Hitler would have had the initiative for a long time. Hitler was hesitant to attack Moscow for reasons not entirely clear to me, but he didn't like Napoleon's capture of that city in 1812.

:S
17 Oct 2015, 09:55

Perhaps you should have added the Battle of Britain as an option, after all if Britain was conquered Hitler could send all those troops and resources to Russia which, in my mind, would have been enough to crush the Soviet union.

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk
17 Oct 2015, 09:57

Yeah, the Battle of Britain was by far the most important.

Forum ArmyField Marshall
Mess with the Bill, you get the scorn!

17 Oct 2015, 09:58

One of the most, It's up there.

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk

Post a Reply

Please log in to post a reply.

Back to Off Topic
Quick Launch