What year to start in Alternate 1914

stardragon225 · 2023-08-03T17:28:01.000Z

What year should the roleplay start in? I originally thought to make it 1914 without the say of the people, but I decieded to try my hand in democracy.

9 Aug 2023, 20:11

Indeed

9 Aug 2023, 20:16

SamPGS_17 wrote:
Carking the 6th wrote:
Germany was definitely more powerful. They managed to defeat Russia, and almost break France a Britain at the same time, while having to prop up their useless allies. Had this been Germany alone VS. France and Russia, I think they would have won.
SamPGS_17 wrote:
Carking the 6th wrote:
SamPGS_17 wrote:
Ah I meant military in general. I always do that. Britain had the strongest military overall…
That’s somewhat debatable at first, since their poorly drilled and some land force at the start really weighed down their navy, allowing dance with a great navy and super strong army to beat UK with a decent army and Super strong navy. As they grew in size and training though, combined with their performance against a major rebellion and 3 world powers, I’d be inclined to agree. They remained the stringers military up until Napoleon.
Perhaps… but they knuckled down essentially after 1801, to form a formal coalition to defeat napoleon. They were certainly the richest nation, and could use that to their advantage, and did.
Still, it took a coalition to bring them down. The UK alone probably was weaker. At least until after 1812.
Not against napoleon - they just didn’t have enough interests there. Napoleon was an insanely good general - with anyone else, the British would just win by default. Essentially the first french revolutionary war was won by napoleon because there was no solid coalition against them, and the British didn’t commit enough. Perhaps you’re right but I would argue for britain being stronger.
in any case, britain were the undisputed strongest power until around the 1930s

You are 100% right economically, but counting generals and that more subjective category, the First French Empire and Imperial Germany were definitely more powerful than Britain. Once the UK committed it still took many coalitions and a lot of effort to take down France. And in WW1, the German army was significantly stronger, while their fleet was rapidly growing in a close second (Anglo-German naval arms race). I also think the US overtook Britain in the 20’s, their massive economic power made it so that when the U.S. would inevitably use its industry, it would rapidly become the most powerful force on Earth (which it did when japan made a mistake).