Changing China's doctrine (HWW)

I'm not sure if this has been posted before but I think that a huge problem of the game is China's doctrine. During WW2, China was part of the Allies and received large amounts of aid to China, however this was after 1941. If we were to use HWW, in 1939, most of Nat China's equipment came from the USSR (250 million dollars of support) and Germany (German trained divisions like the 88th). Very few came from the Japanese and thus I hope Bytro changes it to either Comintern or Axis, but not Pan-Asian. Communist China however, received few support from the Soviets and gained their weapons by stealing the Japanese, so I would change it to Pan-Asian. Thank You.

5 Replies

Lol

Hi3333333333 wrote:

I'm not sure if this has been posted before but I think that a huge problem of the game is China's doctrine. During WW2, China was part of the Allies and received large amounts of aid to China, however this was after 1941. If we were to use HWW, in 1939, most of Nat China's equipment came from the USSR (250 million dollars of support) and Germany (German trained divisions like the 88th). Very few came from the Japanese and thus I hope Bytro changes it to either Comintern or Axis, but not Pan-Asian. Communist China however, received few support from the Soviets and gained their weapons by stealing the Japanese, so I would change it to Pan-Asian. Thank You.
It used to be Axis doctrine, but they changed it because it was way to OP against Japan (unless Japan is played extremely well by a pro against a noob). I would like to see it Comintern though, that would be nice.

_Pyth0n_ wrote:

Hi3333333333 wrote:

I'm not sure if this has been posted before but I think that a huge problem of the game is China's doctrine. During WW2, China was part of the Allies and received large amounts of aid to China, however this was after 1941. If we were to use HWW, in 1939, most of Nat China's equipment came from the USSR (250 million dollars of support) and Germany (German trained divisions like the 88th). Very few came from the Japanese and thus I hope Bytro changes it to either Comintern or Axis, but not Pan-Asian. Communist China however, received few support from the Soviets and gained their weapons by stealing the Japanese, so I would change it to Pan-Asian. Thank You.
It used to be Axis doctrine, but they changed it because it was way to OP against Japan (unless Japan is played extremely well by a pro against a noob). I would like to see it Comintern though, that would be nice.
After the Soviets gave aid, Germany starting stopping the aid and that was around when the Second Sino-Japanese War first started so in 1939, the chance of China's doctrine becoming Comintern is much more likely than Axis. So if Bytro changes, your hope would probably come true.

Now all I have to do is wait till the end of time for Bytro to change the game to my liking, since everyone else's opinions of the game are irrelevant (sarcasm)

:tumbleweed:

Hi3333333333 wrote:

After the Soviets gave aid, Germany starting stopping the aid and that was around when the Second Sino-Japanese War first started so in 1939, the chance of China's doctrine becoming Comintern is much more likely than Axis. So if Bytro changes, your hope would probably come true.
The Germans, under orders from Goring, stopped the shipment of war material to China. When you might ask? April 1938. When did the Soviets began shipping war material? September 1937, and that's just the $250 million credit for weapons. And the Soviets eventually halted most of its deliveries when Operation Barbarossa began.

So the Soviets has little over 2 years of military aid. The Germans had nearly 5 years of aid, both militarily and industrially, alongside 8 elite division. The Stahlhelm M1935 was the main helmet of the National Revolutionary Army during World War II. The Type 24 "Chiang Kai-shek" rifle was a Chinese copy of the StandardModell rifle, the predecessor of the K98. China was the only nation in the war to use the C96 as the primary service pistol of its military and police.

The major advantage of the Type Chiang Kai-shek over the Arisaka was that it had a better rate of fire, a greater range and a better stopping power with the use of the 7.92x57 Mauser cartridge.

So really, German influence of the NRA is too deep for 2 years of Soviet aid to change its standard.

Post a Reply

Please log in to post a reply.

Back to Suggestions
Quick Launch