Locked

Comprehensive Suggestion List

Hello everyone, and welcome to the Call of War unofficial Comprehensive Suggestion List.

The goal of this thread is to list everything that has been suggested on the forums, and categorize them based on what players want. For now, there will be a simple 3 category system, but in the future I may rank some items depending on how important they are, or the frequency of discussion.

Items in the "Positives" section have a general support from most players, and some are very likely to be added in the future. Items in the "Negatives" section have been discussed and have been found to be a feature that should not be added to Call of War. Items in the "Undecided" category have mixed reviews and probably need more discussion to determine whether the majority of players want them or not. So, without further ado...

List of Suggestions for Call of War:

Positive Reviews:

  • Aircraft no longer defending against ground troops when not moving on an airfield
  • Disbanding Units
  • Marines
  • Paratrooper (sorry Bill)
  • Trading technology
  • Larger amount of men per infantry unit
  • Pacific Map
  • Faroe islands
  • Tank Destroyers
  • Coastal Guns
  • Naval Bomber Buff
  • Railroad gun buff
  • Cancel all orders button
  • Radio operators
  • Breaking down buildings
  • Commando rebalance w/ stealth
  • Minelayers + sweeper ships
  • Cruiser variants
  • Corvettes/Patrol Boats
  • Escort ships
  • World Map
  • Kiel Canal
  • Group Conversations
  • Intelligence Station building
  • Ocean Zones (to incentivize island hopping)
  • Other Maps (America, Middle East, Asia, etc.)
  • Group Chat for nations
  • Healing buildings
  • Healing troops
  • Farms/food rebalancing
  • SAM (mix of bomber and fighter)
  • Dynamic view range in different terrain
  • Sort TRADE LIST provinces in alphabetical order
Negative Reviews:

  • Resource Sliders (like S1914)
  • Buffing Infantry
  • Less resource intake from building things (food, manpower, etc.)
  • Tanks/mech inf only using oil when moving
  • More specific types of bombers (subject to change)
  • Multiple ports
  • Old graphics
  • Police
  • Recruiting office
  • Non-core production penalty removal
  • Minimap
  • Super Weapons
  • play as small AI countries
  • Retreating
  • Renaming Provinces
Undecided:

  • Province detail page
  • Kicking active players for RP
  • Prize Wheel (like S1914)
  • Capturing planes
  • Music
  • Wonder Weapons
  • Supply line logistics
  • Different Monetization features
  • Tank destroying aircraft
  • Faster railroads
  • Bunkers
  • Limit on Nukes/Reactors
  • Naming Regiments
  • Province View
  • Weather
  • Encirclement debuffing troops/province
  • Medals for First/Second/Third
  • Choosing where to place airfields within provinces
  • Rivers
  • Gold-free games
  • Gold limits
  • Radar
  • Deconstruction

I'm sure there's plenty of things that I've missed here, so feel free to include any suggestions I may have missed.

689 Replies

Maybe a 50state map, every state, every state dont start with even numbers in troops and res


If Socialists understood Economics, they wouldn't be socialists
-Friedrich von Haye

oceanhawk wrote:

Maybe a 50state map, every state, every state dont start with even numbers in troops and res
What would happen in a 50 state map:

*plays 50 state map*

*gets Delaware/Rhode island/Connecticut*

*leaves*

*plays 50 state again*

*gets Alaska/Hawaii*

*takes 3 days to send troops to attack anyone*

*leaves*

*plays 50 state again*

*gets Michigan/Ohio/Illinois/etc.*

*all your ICs start half destroyed*

*leaves*

*plays 50 state again*

*gets Wyoming*

*starts with no troops or manpower*

*leaves*

*plays 50 state again*

*gets New York*

*entire core gets invaded except NYC*

*wins game*

*plays 50 state again*

*gets Colorado/Utah/Kansas/Nevada/other geometric state*

*invades one province*

*dies from OCD*

you serious?

new york is the 3rd most powerful state

with the 3rd biggest national guard

with the other big states

california and texas far away, I think New york would do pretty well


If Socialists understood Economics, they wouldn't be socialists
-Friedrich von Haye

oceanhawk wrote:

you serious?

new york is the 3rd most powerful state

with the 3rd biggest national guard

with the other big states

california and texas far away, I think New york would do pretty well

The joke was that they would only need NYC to win ;)

Well New york will still have to beat Ohio, not to mentio california, Texas, Florida


If Socialists understood Economics, they wouldn't be socialists
-Friedrich von Haye

comrade dave wrote:

This is a ww2 + game not a short history of the Human race, adding those maps would be rubbish.
Of course it is a WWII game. But that doesn't mean it can't have modded maps. The Road to War map isn't realistic. The Clash of Nations map is REALLY not realistic. And the new World map is insanely unrealistic.

But they are all fun. So why not have modded versions for other eras? When the Civilization series creators opened their front code for modding, it actually made the game much richer. People loved playing Civilzation with it's raw, basic format and/ or with the expansion pack basics. But they also grew to love various other modded versions. They ranged from various and fanciful futuristic versions, to ones that had special rules and only took place over a short segment of a long ago forgotten past. Some mods were fantasy-based and others changed the play rules from civ-building to waypoint reinforcements.

The point of modding is to allow the fan-base the opportunity to contribute to the design and implementation of what they love. The result of modding is a richer, much-thought-out, and vastly-contributed-for-free set of new units, capabilities, story lines, and even certain rule sets. The mechanics of the game have a general "game engine" that never would change. As a programmer, I already know how easy it would be to adapt the game in such a way as to allow modding. A mod simply has a set of updated files that "modify" the external details without changing the engine.

Though this is a web-based game, the same principle of modded files can easily be downloaded automatically when a match is opened just as the core game components are done so. And if any core game components are stored locally on the HDD, so too can sets of modded files and there is no confusion for the system to be able to accommodate a player playing more than one match and/or more than one mod at a time on their computer.

The point (overall) is that modding needs only a little effort by the developers to get started and then a lot of effort by volunteer contributors such as myself to enrich the game by many orders of magnitude.

Finally, the best part of modding, for people like yourself, is that you don't have to use the modded content. Since it's a web-based game, a game purist such as yourself would be unaffected by the mods since you needn't download what you don't use. The only possibly foreseeable issue that modding could have to affect a purist like yourself is that you might find not as many opponents willing to play unmodded matches with you. But, I can't imagine that really being a problem either because Call of War -- as the WWII game that it is at it's core -- will still be beloved by many of us out there; myself included.

It seemed like such a waste to destroy an entire battle station just to eliminate one man. But Charlie knew that it was the only way to ensure the absolute and total destruction of Quasi-duck, once and for all.
The saying, "beating them into submission until payday", is just golden...pun intended.
R.I.P. Snickers <3

#Rant

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk

This has kinda evolved from a Comprehensive Suggestion List, hasn't it...

Definitely. From actually useful stuff, to god knows what.

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk

comrade dave wrote:

#Rant
And I thought I was being quite calm.

;-]

It seemed like such a waste to destroy an entire battle station just to eliminate one man. But Charlie knew that it was the only way to ensure the absolute and total destruction of Quasi-duck, once and for all.
The saying, "beating them into submission until payday", is just golden...pun intended.
R.I.P. Snickers <3

Guess you thought wrong.

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk

I agree with dave

I rather leave the game devlopement to the game devlopers

I think we can maybe a 60s verson

but it cant get too out of hand

I dont really want a cybertron extra nerdy robot wars pls


If Socialists understood Economics, they wouldn't be socialists
-Friedrich von Haye

OMGosh, I would LOVE a Cybertron version with all Transformers as the units (including the infantry, they can be the smaller ones) and instead of building buildings, we build Metroplex(s) and Fortress Maximus(s) and other giant TF's from the 80's.

In fact, that idea is so great, my brain is literally starting to meltdown at the thought.

:D

oceanhawk wrote:

I agree with dave

I rather leave the game devlopement to the game devlopers

Hm...I keep saying how I'd like to BE one of the developers. But, since they aren't hiring, I want to spearhead the modding movement. That's a reasonable demand. Besides, when Civilization was allowed to be modded, tons of wonderful new content was generated by the fan base. How could that be a negative when you don't have to actually use that new content if you don't want or like it?

It seemed like such a waste to destroy an entire battle station just to eliminate one man. But Charlie knew that it was the only way to ensure the absolute and total destruction of Quasi-duck, once and for all.
The saying, "beating them into submission until payday", is just golden...pun intended.
R.I.P. Snickers <3

You can't really mod this game, because all the matches are hosted on Bytro's servers. The best you could do is submit a map idea to Bytro.

They really should allow submitting map ideas though.

How about the world map, but historical (the way the 10 player map is)?

dhhgamer wrote:

How about the world map, but historical (the way the 10 player map is)?
Suggested already by the game developers.
The past is a foreign country.

lol was just reading this guys post then looked at the bottem

"community squad"

lol


If Socialists understood Economics, they wouldn't be socialists
-Friedrich von Haye

Absolute banter.

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk

Prize possession of this alliance


If Socialists understood Economics, they wouldn't be socialists
-Friedrich von Haye

Too true.

British=best. Duh!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tN9EC3Gy6Nk
Back to Suggestions
Quick Launch