Could you allow the demolition of buildings? Sometimes we take over a province that has a factory, but we don't need another factory. It would be nice to demolish it and reclaim some resources.
Talked about this many many times. We agreed that it would cost res to demolish.
Why would you demolish a factory anyway? You always need more factories!
I was just going to make a post about this exact same idea. Since the follow-up rebuttal wasn't well thought out, let me elaborate on the idea.
1) Resource Cost to Demolish- I actually agree with this, but, the only cost should be Manpower and Time, and maybe Food. Why would you use anything else when you aren't building something?
2) The concept that you always need more Factories might be true. But why would you build a Factory in a Province with no resources? Why would you build anything in a Province with no resources? I can see maybe Airfields, if your strategy employs them. Perhaps Naval Yards, if your strategy employs them. But for the bulk of players, like myself, we only use Armies to take out our enemies. Demolishing a Factory in a Province with no resources, or any other building for that matter, only makes sense.
3) Demolishing could be an extremely useful Tactic in a slugfest with another player. If you're constantly going back and forth in a region, or over even a single Province, razing the buildings would only help you. Why give your enemy something they can use against you?
Bulldozers etc need to be built to do the job.BrutalArt1st wrote:
Why would you use anything else when you aren't building something?
The AI builds it and it can come in handy.BrutalArt1st wrote:
But why would you build a Factory in a Province with no resources? Why would you build anything in a Province with no resources
lol noobBrutalArt1st wrote:
But for the bulk of players, like myself, we only use Armies to take out our enemies.
That is a Scorched Earth type thing, something we have already talked about.BrutalArt1st wrote:
Demolishing could be an extremely useful Tactic in a slugfest with another player
Another benefit to demolishing is that the factory or other building you just acquired in a new province might be useless to you if it is in the wrong location. If you're playing Russia, for example, you have the edge of the map on one side, and any factories you might win in eastern Turkey or Arabia would be useless to you if the bulk of your fighting is in eastern or central Europe. Why build a new unit way the heck in eastern Turkey only to waste several days to march it into battle against Germany? It would be nice to demolish buildings or airfields or navy bases in areas deep within your territory where you don't need them.
And really, bulldozers? Are you saying bulldozers take up more resources than a naval base or factory? You don't have to rebuild brand new bulldozers every time you tear down a building. Bulldozers can be reused you know.
Long supply lines, yes, but those factories are very safe if you start to lose and you can also attack Yugo and NA.Enlightened2 wrote:
Why build a new unit way the heck in eastern Turkey only to waste several days to march it into battle against German
So you want to have a bulldozer as unit so you can reuse it?Enlightened2 wrote:
Are you saying bulldozers take up more resources than a naval base or factory
Heck, while we're at it, let's introduce construction units as a requirement to build buildings.Butter Ball Bill wrote:
Enlightened2 wrote:So you want to have a bulldozer as unit so you can reuse it?Enlightened2 wrote:
Are you saying bulldozers take up more resources than a naval base or factory
No but I do have sarcasm.Butter Ball Bill wrote:
WTF?! No! That sucks! Are you fcking disabled?
I would highly advise against using sarcasm on the net, it is much harder to tell when you can't here the persons tone of voice.IISpikeII wrote:
No but I do have sarcasm.
Please log in to post a reply.
